HAMBURG, N.Y. – The Allegheny Mountain College Conference released the 2025 Baseball All-Conference Teams and Individual Award Winners today, and Hilbert College earned six honorees.
Graduate RP
Joe Reitebach and sophomore OF
Joey Haynes were selected to the First Team, senior P
Dylan Moorhouse, sophomore 1B
Dustin Hendrix and graduate UTIL
Kyle Borrello were named to the Second Team, and senior DH
Jack Duffek, was placed on the Third Team.
Pitt-Greensburg took home both Player of the Year (James Domer) and Pitcher of the Year (Conner Burkey), while Jordan Hughes of Alfred State earned Newcomer of the Year honors. Regular and Postseason Champions Penn State Behrend saw its manager, Paul Benim, earn Coach of the Year.
Joe Reitebach (Orchard Park, NY/Hamburg HS | Gannon University) finished seventh in the AMCC in ERA (3.18) and fourteenth in K/9 (6.35) in 17 conference innings. Overall, Reitebach led Hilbert with a 2.61 ERA and finished second on the team with a 1.39 WHIP across twelve total appearances.
Joey Haynes (Niagara Wheatfield, NY/St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | Canisius College) led the conference in batting average (.528), hits (28), OBP (.621), and stolen bases (eight) in his first season with the Hawks. Haynes also finished third in runs (17), and seventh in slugging percentage (.660) in his first year at Hilbert.
Dylan Moorhouse (Williamsville, NY/Williamsville East | Erie Community College) completed his second-straight All-Conference campaign ranked third in the AMCC in Wins (four), fourth in IP (30.2), eighth in K/9 (7.34) and 13th in ERA (4.40). Moorhouse's 44 strikeouts and 52 IP both topped the Hilbert pitching staff in his second season with the Royal and White.
Dustin Hendrix (Lakewood, NY/Southwestern) finished top ten in the conference in a pair of categories (RBI, third – 17, Slugging %, sixth - .667) in his sophomore campaign. Hendrix earned D3baseball.com Team of the Week honors earlier this spring on his way to slashing .325/.416/.528 in 35 starts.
Kyle Borrello (Hamburg, NY/Hamburg HS | Gannon University) topped the conference in slugging percentage (.889) while also ranking second in OBP (.600), second in HRs (four), and sixth in Batting Average (.407) in his first season as a Hawk. The Gannon University transfer hit .328 with 22 RBI and a team-leading 1.140 OPS this spring.
Jack Duffek (Orchard Park, NY/Orchard Park | Allegheny) earned a second-straight AMCC Third-Team nod after finishing the season second in HRs (four) and third in RBI (17). In a season that saw Duffek reach the 100 RBI milestone, the senior DH posted a .339 average with five home runs, 28 RBI, a .545 slugging percentage and 66 total bases.
This year's Hilbert team continued to elevate the baseball program's success under Coach Drew Fittry's guidance. The Hawks earned a fifth-straight postseason bid, while finishing just one win shy of a third-consecutive 20-win campaign.
Dustin Hendrix and
Patrick Evans were named the 2025 AMCC All-Tournament team.
